Macintosh XL
 | |
| Macintosh XL with MacWorks XL software | |
| Specifications | |
|---|---|
| Developer | Apple Computer, Inc. |
| Manufacturer | Apple Computer, Inc. |
| Type | Personal/business computer |
| Released | January 1, 1985 |
| Discontinued | April 29, 1985 (production) August 1, 1985 (official) |
| Intro price | US$3,995 |
| Units sold | ~3,500–5,000 |
| CPU | Motorola 68000 @ 5 MHz |
| Memory | 512 KB RAM standard (expandable to 2 MB) |
| Storage | 1 × 3.5″ floppy (400 KB) + 10 MB Widget HDD |
| Display | 12″ monochrome CRT, 720 × 364 pixels (rectangular) 608 × 432 pixels (square with Screen Kit) |
| Sound | Internal piezo speaker (no Mac sound hardware) |
| Dimensions | 15.2″ H × 18.7″ W × 14.4″ D |
| Weight | 48 lb (21.8 kg) |
| OS / Firmware | MacWorks XL (Mac System 1.1–3.2) MacWorks Plus (up to System 6.0.3) MacWorks Plus II (up to System 7.5.5) |
| Predecessor | Apple Lisa 2 |
| Successor | None (replaced by Macintosh Plus) |
| Codename | N/A (rebrand of Lisa 2/10) |
| Model no. | A6S0200 |
The Macintosh XL was Apple Computer's final attempt to salvage the failing Lisa platform by repositioning it as a high-end Macintosh computer. Released on January 1, 1985, the Macintosh XL was essentially a rebadged Lisa 2/10 bundled with MacWorks XL, a software environment that enabled 64K Macintosh ROM emulation. Despite initial success that exceeded Apple's conservative projections, the company discontinued the Macintosh XL after just four months when component supplies were exhausted, making it one of the shortest-lived products in Apple's history. Macintosh XL, Wikipedia—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
Origins and Market Strategy
The Lisa Crisis
By late 1984, the Lisa platform was in critical condition. Despite the introduction of the more affordable Lisa 2 models earlier that year, sales remained dismal compared to the Macintosh, which had sold over 50,000 units in its first 100 days. MacWorks XL, Wikipedia—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
Apple faced a dilemma: significant inventory of Lisa hardware remained unsold, and the company had already committed to discontinuing Lisa production.
Macintosh Office Initiative
The Macintosh XL was announced at Apple's January 1985 annual meeting as part of the "Macintosh Office" strategy, which aimed to position the Macintosh family as a complete business solution. Macintosh XL, Wikipedia—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
The XL would serve as the high-end Macintosh, offering features that the original Mac lacked:
- Built-in hard drive (10 MB Widget)
- Expandable memory (up to 2 MB vs. 512 KB maximum on Mac 512K)
- Larger 12″ display
- Three internal expansion slots
Pricing Strategy
At US$3,995, the Macintosh XL was positioned between the Macintosh 512K (US$2,795) and what would become the Macintosh Plus (US$2,599 base). The price represented a further reduction from the Lisa 2/10's US$5,495 list price, reflecting Apple's desperate attempt to clear inventory. Macintosh XL, Apple Wiki—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
Hardware Architecture
Core Specifications
The Macintosh XL retained the Lisa 2/10's hardware unchanged, with MacWorks XL providing the Macintosh compatibility layer:
| Component | Specification | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| CPU | Motorola 68000 @ 5 MHz | 20% slower than Mac's 7.83 MHz |
| RAM | 512 KB standard | Expandable to 2 MB (4 MB with mods) |
| ROM | Lisa ROM + MacWorks XL | 64K Mac ROM emulated in software |
| Display | 720 × 364 pixels | Rectangular pixels (3:4 aspect ratio) |
| Display (with Screen Kit) | 608 × 432 pixels | Square pixels like Macintosh |
| Storage | 400 KB 3.5″ floppy + 10 MB Widget | Internal hard drive standard |
| Expansion | 3 Lisa slots | Not compatible with Mac peripherals |
Display System
Rectangular Pixel Issue
Unlike all true Macintosh computers, the stock Macintosh XL displayed rectangular pixels with a 3:4 width-to-height ratio. This caused significant distortion when running Macintosh software: Square Dots– Andy Hertzfeld, Folklore.org—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
- Circles appeared as vertical ovals
- Squares looked like tall rectangles
- All graphics appeared stretched vertically
Macintosh XL Screen Kit
Apple offered the Macintosh XL Screen Kit to address the pixel aspect ratio problem. The kit included: The Apple Lisa FAQ, Lisa FAQ—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
- New 3A boot ROMs
- Modified video state ROM
- Replacement yoke coil for the CRT
- Installation instructions
The Screen Kit changed the display resolution from 720×364 to 608×432 pixels, providing:
- True square pixels matching the Macintosh
- 50% more screen area than the Mac's 512×342 display
- WYSIWYG compatibility with Macintosh software
- Professional appearance for graphics applications
Memory Architecture
The Macintosh XL's memory configuration provided significant advantages over contemporary Macintoshes: Was the Mac XL hardware different from the last versions of the Lisa?, Retrocomputing Stack Exchange—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
- Base configuration: 512 KB using 256K×1 DRAM chips
- Expansion options:
- 512 KB card (1 MB total)
- 1.5 MB card (2 MB total)
- Third-party modifications up to 4 MB
- XLerator board up to 8 MB
Storage Subsystem
Widget Hard Drive
The 10 MB Widget drive was standard equipment, providing:
- 65 ms average seek time
- Built-in controller with diagnostic ROM
- Direct parallel port connection
- Significantly faster than external ProFile drives
Floppy Drive
Single Sony 400 KB 3.5″ drive (MP-F51W):
- Variable speed rotation (394-590 RPM)
- Single-sided operation
- Compatible with Macintosh disks under MacWorks
- Upgradeable to 800 KB with Sun Remarketing kit
MacWorks XL Software
Development History
MacWorks originated as an internal Apple project to use Lisa hardware for Macintosh software development, addressing the original Mac's severe limitations: An informal history of Macintosh "emulation": 1984-1996 MacWorks for Lisa, Stories of Apple—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
- 128 KB RAM insufficient for serious development
- No hard disk support
- Limited screen size for development tools
Technical Implementation
MacWorks XL provided software emulation of the 64K Macintosh ROM, allowing the Lisa hardware to run Mac System Software and applications. MacWorks XL, Wikipedia—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
The emulation layer included:
- Complete 64K ROM routine implementation
- Hardware abstraction layer for Lisa-specific components
- Memory management translation
- Device driver mappings
Boot Process
The MacWorks XL boot sequence required two diskettes:
- **MacWorks XL Boot Disk:** Loaded the Mac OS bootloader
- **MacWorks XL System Disk:** Contained System 3.2 and Finder
After initial boot, the system displayed a white screen, ejected the first disk, and showed the familiar blinking question mark with a Macintosh XL graphic.
Limitations
MacWorks XL had several significant limitations:
- Maximum System 3.2 support (64K ROM limitation)
- No sound beyond system beep (lacked Mac sound hardware)
- Rectangular pixel distortion without Screen Kit
- Some Mac software incompatible due to hardware differences
- Performance penalty from emulation layer
Production and Sales
Manufacturing Constraints
Apple's conservative production planning proved catastrophic. Based on poor Lisa sales history, the company ordered only enough parts to last through 1985. Macintosh XL, Wikipedia—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
Key decisions included:
- No new manufacturing—only rebadging existing Lisa 2/10 units
- Limited component inventory for repairs and upgrades
- No provision for production line restart
Unexpected Success
The Macintosh XL's US$3,995 price point and built-in hard drive generated unexpected demand: The Lisa, MacStories, 2020-01-27—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
- Record orders in Q1 1985
- Sales rate triple that of Lisa 2
- Entire 1985 allocation sold by April 29
- Backlog of unfulfilled orders
Premature Discontinuation
By April 29, 1985, Apple had exhausted its parts inventory. CEO John Sculley later admitted that continuing production would have lost money on each unit due to the Lisa's expensive architecture. Apple Lisa, Wikipedia—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
The official discontinuation came August 1, 1985, leaving an eight-month gap before the Macintosh Plus launch.
Sun Remarketing Era
Acquisition and Continuation
After Apple's discontinuation, Sun Remarketing of Logan, Utah, purchased remaining inventory and the MacWorks license. Sun Remarketing, Wikipedia—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
Sun's involvement included:
- Purchasing ~5,000-7,000 unsold units
- Acquiring MacWorks XL development rights
- Providing ongoing support for installed base
- Developing hardware upgrades
MacWorks Plus Development
Sun Remarketing commissioned Chuck Lukaszewski to develop MacWorks Plus, addressing the original's limitations: MacWorks Plus, Wikipedia—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
| Version | Developer | Release | Max System | Key Features |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MacWorks 1.0 | Apple | April 1984 | 3.2 | Floppy only, no hard disk |
| MacWorks 2.0/3.0 | Apple | Fall 1984 | 3.2 | Hard disk support added |
| MacWorks XL | Apple | January 1985 | 3.2 | Bundled with Mac XL |
| MacWorks Plus | Sun/Lukaszewski | August 1988 | 6.0.3 | 128K ROM, HFS, 800K floppy |
| MacWorks Plus II | Dafax/Query | 1990s | 7.5.5 | Maximum 68000 compatibility |
Hardware Upgrades
Sun Remarketing offered several upgrades: MacWorks Plus: Making A Lisa Speak Macintosh, Call-A.P.P.L.E.—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
- 800 KB double-sided floppy drives
- 20 MB and 40 MB internal hard drives
- Memory expansion to 2 MB
- "Macintosh Professional" rebrand
XLerator Board
Third-party developers created the XLerator 18 CPU replacement:
- 16 MHz 68000 processor (3× faster)
- 4 SIMM slots for up to 8 MB RAM
- Optional 68881/68882 FPU
- Optional SCSI interface
Development Platform Legacy
Software Development Role
The Macintosh XL served a crucial but often overlooked role as the primary development platform for early Macintosh software: Lisa/Lisa 2/Mac XL, Apple-History.com—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
- Used by Apple for Mac system software development
- Essential for third-party developers before Mac development tools
- Faster compilation than Mac 512K despite slower CPU
- Larger screen beneficial for development environments
Performance Advantages
Despite the 5 MHz CPU (vs. Mac's 7.83 MHz), the XL offered advantages:
- More RAM reduced disk swapping
- Built-in hard drive eliminated floppy shuffling
- 12″ screen displayed more code
- Compile times often faster than Mac SE
User Exchange Program
In 1986, Apple offered Macintosh XL owners a trade-in program: Macintosh XL, Wikipedia—link(accessed 2025-01-25)
- Trade XL + US$1,495 for Macintosh Plus and Hard Disk 20
- Total package value of US$4,098
- Program aimed to eliminate support obligations
- Many users opted to keep their XLs
Common Issues and Maintenance
Power Supply Problems
The Macintosh XL inherited the Lisa's power supply issues:
- Capacitor degradation after 30+ years
- Voltage drift requiring adjustment
- Thermal stress on regulators
- RIFA capacitor explosions
Widget Drive Failures
The 10 MB Widget drive has specific failure modes:
- Servo control board failures
- Head crashes (usually irreparable)
- Controller board errors
- Mechanical seizure from old lubricants
Display Issues
- Geometry distortion from aging capacitors
- Yoke connector cold solder joints
- CRT phosphor burn-in
- Screen Kit installation challenges
Memory Problems
- SIMM socket oxidation
- Address decoder PAL failures
- RAM chip failures
- Incompatible third-party memory
Collecting and Preservation
Current Market
Macintosh XL systems have become highly collectible:
- Working systems: US$3,000-8,000 (2024 prices)
- With Screen Kit: Premium 20-30%
- With MacWorks Plus: Additional premium
- Complete documentation: Rare and valuable
Restoration Priorities
Modern restoration typically involves:
- Complete capacitor replacement (critical)
- Widget drive rehabilitation or replacement
- Screen Kit installation if not present
- MacWorks Plus installation
- Memory expansion to 2 MB
- Modern storage solutions (SCSI2SD)
Parts Availability
- Widget drives: Extremely rare, often rebuilt
- Screen Kits: Very rare, command high prices
- Memory boards: Available from donor Lisas
- MacWorks media: Available from user groups
Historical Significance
Bridge Product
The Macintosh XL represented a critical transition:
- Last Lisa-based product
- First "expandable" Macintosh
- Proved market demand for high-end Macs
- Influenced Macintosh Plus development
Market Impact
Despite its brief life, the XL demonstrated:
- Business market wanted expandable Macs
- Built-in hard drives were essential
- Larger displays had professional appeal
- Price/performance balance was critical
Development Influence
The XL's role in software development was significant:
- Enabled creation of major Mac applications
- Supported development until Mac II release
- Proved value of cross-platform development tools
- Influenced Apple's developer support strategy
Technical Documentation
Official Apple Resources
- Macintosh XL Owner's Guide (030-1040-A)
- MacWorks XL Manual (030-1042-A)
- Macintosh XL Service Manual (072-0090-A)
- Technical Note #88: MacWorks XL Compatibility
Third-Party Documentation
- Sun Remarketing MacWorks Plus Manual
- Do-It-Yourself Guide (Sun Remarketing)
- XLerator Installation Guide
- Screen Kit Installation Instructions
Specifications Summary
| Feature | Mac 512K | Macintosh XL | Mac Plus |
|---|---|---|---|
| CPU Speed | 7.83 MHz | 5 MHz | 8 MHz |
| Standard RAM | 512 KB | 512 KB | 1 MB |
| Maximum RAM | 512 KB | 2 MB (4 MB mod) | 4 MB |
| Display Size | 9″ | 12″ | 9″ |
| Resolution | 512×342 | 720×364 / 608×432 | 512×342 |
| Internal HD | No | 10 MB standard | No (20 MB external) |
| Expansion Slots | 0 | 3 (Lisa slots) | 0 |
| List Price | US$2,795 | US$3,995 | US$2,599 |
See Also
References
External Links
- Ray Arachelian's Lisa FAQ
- LisaList Archives
- Vintage Mac World - Widget Information
- 68kMLA Forums - Lisa/Mac XL Section